The Greek Supreme Court (Areios Pagos) has put the brakes on the hopes of thousands of workers who have been employed in the public sector for years through successive fixed-term contracts under special employment programs administered by DYPA (the Greek Public Employment Service). The ruling carries significant implications for the 27,500 workers currently employed in public services, hospitals, and other public bodies through DYPA programs, many of whom have remained in the same positions for extended periods of time.
A glaring paradox
This case brings to light a striking paradox at the heart of Greece’s public sector employment reality: on one hand, public bodies have relied on these workers for years to keep their services running, covering permanent operational needs; on the other hand, those same workers remain in a state of precarious, temporary employment, with no automatic right to a stable employment relationship.
The issue has drawn the attention of the government. According to sources, informal discussions have begun between the Ministries of Finance, Interior, and Labour on whether — and how — a permanent solution could be found for workers who have accumulated years of experience, without violating the constitutional rules governing public sector hiring.
At the forefront of the debate are workers who have completed several years of service through successive fixed-term contracts outside DYPA programs. Although they technically lack the status of permanent civil servants, in practice they have become integrated into the daily operations of public services and fulfill ongoing operational needs.
This category of workers argues that it is simply untenable for a working relationship that has lasted years in practice to be treated as “temporary.” On the other side, the state cannot automatically convert all fixed-term contracts into open-ended ones, as strict constitutional and institutional constraints are firmly in place.
The court’s approach in this ruling is notably strict: it draws a clear distinction between a public body’s actual need for workers and the legal permissibility of converting their contracts. In other words, even when a worker has remained in the same post for years, performing the same daily duties and meeting the functional needs of a public body, this does not automatically confer the right to permanent status or conversion to an open-ended contract.
The case that triggered the ruling
The case involves a worker who was placed at the Florina Health Centre in 2017 as a medical laboratory technologist, under the special employment program for 4,000 long-term unemployed individuals in the public health sector. Her initial contract lasted 12 months. However, it was subsequently renewed through successive 12-month extensions, with the result that she continued working at the same healthcare unit until February 2022 — a total of approximately five years in the public health system.
The program had originally been designed to address long-term unemployment and to strengthen public healthcare facilities with additional staff. Over time, however, successive government decisions extended its duration, allowing beneficiaries to remain in the same positions for longer. The worker took her case to court, seeking recognition that the termination of her employment was invalid and that her contract should be deemed open-ended. She argued, in essence, that the repeated renewals could not be treated as independent contracts, since in practice they served the ongoing needs of the public body.
Initially, the Single-Member Court of First Instance of Thessaloniki ruled in her favour. However, the case took a different turn at the Court of Appeal, which in 2024 overturned the first-instance ruling and dismissed the claim. The worker then filed an appeal on points of law before the Supreme Court, seeking to overturn the appellate decision. The Areios Pagos examined the case and dismissed the appeal in its entirety, effectively upholding the judicial finding that the specific contract had expired automatically upon the completion of its agreed term.
Article 103 of the Greek Constitution
The core legal argument underpinning the court’s decision is the constitutional prohibition on converting fixed-term contracts into open-ended ones within the public and broader public sector. Specifically, Article 103, paragraph 8 of the Greek Constitution explicitly prohibits the permanent appointment of staff recruited under private law employment relationships to cover the needs set out in that provision, as well as the conversion of their contracts into open-ended ones.
This particular constitutional provision, which was introduced through the 2001 revision, aims to safeguard meritocracy, transparency, and equality in public sector recruitment. The hiring of permanent staff must follow established procedures — either through competitive examination or based on objective criteria — and must be subject to oversight by ASEP (the Supreme Council for Civil Personnel Selection).
According to the Supreme Court, this prohibition cannot be circumvented by invoking the fact that workers are in practice covering permanent and ongoing needs. Even if employees have worked in the same service for years, performing duties that form part of its daily operations, it cannot automatically be inferred that they have acquired an open-ended employment relationship. The ruling also reaffirms that, following the 2001 constitutional revision, it is not possible to invoke Law 2112/1920 to have contracts concluded with public bodies after that revision recognized as open-ended — even where those contracts cover permanent and ongoing needs.
A program for the unemployed
The program was based on Article 64 of Law 4430/2016, which allowed groups of unemployed individuals to be placed in special public sector employment programs. Beneficiaries were selected by DYPA based on each program’s eligibility conditions and criteria, while ASEP played a supervisory role to ensure the legality and transparency of the process.
The critical detail in this case lies in the terms of the ministerial decision governing the program for 4,000 long-term unemployed workers in the healthcare sector. The decision specifies that contracts are fixed-term in nature and that, upon expiry of the stipulated period, they terminate automatically — with no compensation and no requirement for a formal confirmatory act.
Furthermore, the same decision explicitly states that any extension or conclusion of a new contract within the same calendar year, as well as any conversion to an open-ended contract, is null and void. The fact that contracts were extended through successive ministerial decisions does not, in the Supreme Court’s assessment, mean that their fundamental character was altered. The extensions were part of the specific operational framework of the program and did not eliminate the temporary nature of the employment. Put simply, years spent in the same post are not in themselves sufficient to give rise to a right to permanent employment, when the original hiring was made under a special program with a defined duration and automatic expiry.
Abuse of successive contracts
In its reasoning, the Supreme Court also examined the framework of Presidential Decree 164/2004, which transposed EU Directive 1999/70/EC on the prevention of abuse of successive fixed-term contracts. The decree establishes rules on successive contracts and the conditions under which abusive renewals may be challenged. However, in this case a critical exception applies: Article 2, paragraph 2 of Presidential Decree 164/2004 explicitly excludes from its scope contracts concluded under special training, integration, and vocational retraining programs supported by OAED (the former Greek Manpower Employment Organisation, now DYPA).
This exclusion is of particular significance, as it limits the ability to invoke the protective framework of the directive as grounds for seeking the conversion of such contracts into open-ended ones. As a result, the mere existence of successive renewals is not in itself sufficient to establish abuse when the employment falls under a special program with defined terms and a fixed time horizon.
Originally published in Apogevmatini